If you did Innocent Scoundrel, Like Moths to a Candle, or Buried Secrets, then The Broken Spearhead will no longer be available. You should get The Spearhead's Captain or The Spearhead's Crew instead though.
@Mephane I assume you completed one of those three quests after aborting The Broken Spearhead? From what you have said, it sounds like you finished Innocent Scoundrel and Jakarn is going to give you The Spearhead's Captain. You could try talking to Kaleen instead of picking up that quest from Jakarn, but I don't know what that will do. If you can't get The Broken Spearhead again, then the only difference is a couple of lines of dialogue and missing out on 85 Gold and 54 XP, which is not a big deal in the long run.If only I had known 10 minutes earlier. Not knowing any of the NPCs to recruit, In the original dialog I just picked Lerisa. Then I soon met Jakarn first in the to free him and then into the goblin cave. I like the character and decided I would recruit him instead, so I aborted "The Broken Spearhead"... big mistake. Now I cannot get that quest again. Jakarn however now offers me a quest which leads to him being recruited, butIf you did Innocent Scoundrel, Like Moths to a Candle, or Buried Secrets, then The Broken Spearhead will no longer be available. You should get The Spearhead's Captain or The Spearhead's Crew instead though.
a) I have permanently missed out on "The Broken Spearhead", which also means my total quest count forever is 1 less that it could be, should be.
b) The way Captain Kaleen now talks to me in this new quest, it is more like some random stranger who approaches her in the tavern, as opposed to before after she rescued me when I was basically automatically considered part of the crew.
In any single player RPG, that would be the moment to immediately reload a previous save. But no, this being an MMO, it's been broken permanently. I've lost all my will to even to keep going with this story and questing, knowing I have unknowingly sabotaged it.