For the reasons I gave. There is no effective and open public trading system, only a limited system that restricts selling to comparatively few players at distorted prices that do not reflect supply and demand because, in addition to supply being artificially restricted, demand is ineffective given that most buyers aren't interested in travelling the world to find items and price check them. There will be very many players who don't even participate in the economy.
For the reasons I gave. There is no effective and open public trading system, only a limited system that restricts selling to comparatively few players at distorted prices that do not reflect supply and demand because, in addition to supply being artificially restricted, demand is ineffective given that most buyers aren't interested in travelling the world to find items and price check them. There will be very many players who don't even participate in the economy.
Alphashado wrote: »
For the reasons I gave. There is no effective and open public trading system, only a limited system that restricts selling to comparatively few players at distorted prices that do not reflect supply and demand because, in addition to supply being artificially restricted, demand is ineffective given that most buyers aren't interested in travelling the world to find items and price check them. There will be very many players who don't even participate in the economy.
I disagree. People will still happily get into their car and drive across town to a Walmart, then drive to the other side of town in order to go Best Buy, then get back in their car again and drive all the way to the next town in order go to the Mall. For no other reason than variety and bargain shopping.
Separate Kiosks are no different than different retail stores. People will shop around, compare prices, and go where the best prices are. A kiosk with the best prices will get more business or a kiosk with the best location might get more business. Again, no different than different stores scattered around town.
When the entire time they could be shopping online from the comfort of their desk. But they don't. Wallmart and Best Buy are always jam packed with people even though 90% of those people could just as easily shop the same stores from home.
Alphashado wrote: »
For the reasons I gave. There is no effective and open public trading system, only a limited system that restricts selling to comparatively few players at distorted prices that do not reflect supply and demand because, in addition to supply being artificially restricted, demand is ineffective given that most buyers aren't interested in travelling the world to find items and price check them. There will be very many players who don't even participate in the economy.
I disagree. People will still happily get into their car and drive across town to a Walmart, then drive to the other side of town in order to go Best Buy, then get back in their car again and drive all the way to the next town in order go to the Mall. For no other reason than variety and bargain shopping.
Separate Kiosks are no different than different retail stores. People will shop around, compare prices, and go where the best prices are. A kiosk with the best prices will get more business or a kiosk with the best location might get more business. Again, no different than different stores scattered around town.
When the entire time they could be shopping online from the comfort of their desk. But they don't. Wallmart and Best Buy are always jam packed with people even though 90% of those people could just as easily shop the same stores from home.
Ignoring the fact that like most forum analogies it doesn't really compare, these days people won't reckon to drive from store to store let alone town to town without first researching where the best prices are - and you can't do that with the guild kiosk system, you have to search through each trader in turn. As for in-game, if people these days need a punctuation mark over quest givers and a mark on the map to show where they have to go next, how many do you think are willing to travel around the world checking out each trader's stock and prices?
But if you want to rely on your analogy, what would you think of a system in real life where each store let out its shelves on weekly auctions to the highest bidder and the successful suppliers were the only ones that could market their goods that week? I don't think it would prove too popular, do you? It certainly wouldn't last long.
Alphashado wrote: »Alphashado wrote: »
For the reasons I gave. There is no effective and open public trading system, only a limited system that restricts selling to comparatively few players at distorted prices that do not reflect supply and demand because, in addition to supply being artificially restricted, demand is ineffective given that most buyers aren't interested in travelling the world to find items and price check them. There will be very many players who don't even participate in the economy.
I disagree. People will still happily get into their car and drive across town to a Walmart, then drive to the other side of town in order to go Best Buy, then get back in their car again and drive all the way to the next town in order go to the Mall. For no other reason than variety and bargain shopping.
Separate Kiosks are no different than different retail stores. People will shop around, compare prices, and go where the best prices are. A kiosk with the best prices will get more business or a kiosk with the best location might get more business. Again, no different than different stores scattered around town.
When the entire time they could be shopping online from the comfort of their desk. But they don't. Wallmart and Best Buy are always jam packed with people even though 90% of those people could just as easily shop the same stores from home.
Ignoring the fact that like most forum analogies it doesn't really compare, these days people won't reckon to drive from store to store let alone town to town without first researching where the best prices are - and you can't do that with the guild kiosk system, you have to search through each trader in turn. As for in-game, if people these days need a punctuation mark over quest givers and a mark on the map to show where they have to go next, how many do you think are willing to travel around the world checking out each trader's stock and prices?
But if you want to rely on your analogy, what would you think of a system in real life where each store let out its shelves on weekly auctions to the highest bidder and the successful suppliers were the only ones that could market their goods that week? I don't think it would prove too popular, do you? It certainly wouldn't last long.
Global Auction House = Internet shopping/Giant retail stores
Kiosks = Mom and Pop shops.
/shrug. To me the kiosk system feels like a collection of mom and pop stores compared to one giant retail store or internet shopping. Sure, the prices are usually higher at mom and pop stores, but they are each unique and self sufficient, and they still must compete with each other in order to retain customers.
I wouldn't have any problem at all with changing the system like putting all the kiosks in Strip mall type shopping centers, or even marking them on the map. I don't even have a problem with smaller, regional auction houses. But ZoS has repeatedly stated that a global AH is the only other option. And after playing Gw2 and seeing first hand how such a system absolutely waters down an economy, I am not interested in seeing it here. Plus it would destroy any sense of accomplishment you get from crafting.
Alright.
But I do not share your description of ESOs economy eco-system. We may only have 2 different views.
I do respect your view and will give you mine. Please don't take this as an "I am right, you are wrong".
We definitely don't need a global AH.
BUT they should certainly make the current guild store interface better! Man, that thing is terrible! WE NEED A TEXT SEARCH BOX. I cannot understand why they didn't build in something so simple and valuable.
Get with the program ZOS!
Alphashado wrote: »
For the reasons I gave. There is no effective and open public trading system, only a limited system that restricts selling to comparatively few players at distorted prices that do not reflect supply and demand because, in addition to supply being artificially restricted, demand is ineffective given that most buyers aren't interested in travelling the world to find items and price check them. There will be very many players who don't even participate in the economy.
I disagree. People will still happily get into their car and drive across town to a Walmart, then drive to the other side of town in order to go Best Buy, then get back in their car again and drive all the way to the next town in order go to the Mall. For no other reason than variety and bargain shopping.
Separate Kiosks are no different than different retail stores. People will shop around, compare prices, and go where the best prices are. So it absolutely reflects supply and demand because if someone is asking too much for an item on one guild trader, a player can just go shop at a different one. A kiosk with the best prices will get more business or a kiosk with the best location might get more business. Again, no different than different stores scattered around town.
When the entire time they could be shopping online from the comfort of their desk. But they don't. Wallmart and Best Buy are always jam packed with people even though 90% of those people could just as easily shop the same stores from home.
Alright.
But I do not share your description of ESOs economy eco-system. We may only have 2 different views.
I do respect your view and will give you mine. Please don't take this as an "I am right, you are wrong".
Thanks for setting out your view, and doing so respectfully. I share your desire to discuss such things rationally and politely!
My big complaint with the present ESO system is that it makes buying cumbersome, restricts selling based on guild membership and weekly bidding, and inflates prices through failing to match supply and demand in an effective way. You take a different view and I respect that, but I cannot comment on how it works in EVE as it isn't a game I've played. However, I have listed a number of games in another post above where I have played an auction house system of trading without any problems.
I still stand to my word, its not the kiosks vs. AH topic, but more one of accessibility. If we players could use guild vendors independently of our membership, then everyone could contribute to the economy and not just a few players.
As far I can tell, we do have 90% of dead kiosks, where nothing happens and 10% that are alive. Unfortunately are people who are not a member of those guilds that own the kiosks, restricted to only buy, but not sell. An economy that is only based on buy, but not sell is doomed.
I don't understand why ZO made it this way, I have honestly not see this type of system before. In every MMO I played we could buy & sell, or have our own shops to sell if we didn't join the trade guilds & cartels.
Alright.
But I do not share your description of ESOs economy eco-system. We may only have 2 different views.
I do respect your view and will give you mine. Please don't take this as an "I am right, you are wrong".
Thanks for setting out your view, and doing so respectfully. I share your desire to discuss such things rationally and politely!
My big complaint with the present ESO system is that it makes buying cumbersome, restricts selling based on guild membership and weekly bidding, and inflates prices through failing to match supply and demand in an effective way. You take a different view and I respect that, but I cannot comment on how it works in EVE as it isn't a game I've played. However, I have listed a number of games in another post above where I have played an auction house system of trading without any problems.
An auction house will effectively kill all Guild Stores and invalidate them.
It would also drive the price of everything to the lowest possible (mean) figure and also remove any chance of bargains for those intrepid travellers out there that do bother to explore and go to other guild trade sites in other areas.
Gone will be the days where you can pick up a Barbarian Motif for 5k
You know, out of all the threads and posts I read and or skimmed though about this subject, this post is the one that actually changed my mind on wanting a centralized AH system. Simple and to the point.
Two good solid points @P3ZZL3
I hope ZOS do not add an AH.
I think the economy is one of the best in an MMO, we don't have crazy inflation and i personally feel like if i put in the effort i can get some really good deals that an AH would all but eliminate.
The way it works now is that there is no price point for everyone to work against meaning that people buy and sell based on what they feel the items is worth.
It also allows for more bartering which i love.
Im sorry so many of you don't like this but you can just play the game and get the items you want that way!!
Good luck!
We definitely don't need a global AH.
BUT they should certainly make the current guild store interface better! Man, that thing is terrible! WE NEED A TEXT SEARCH BOX. I cannot understand why they didn't build in something so simple and valuable.
Get with the program ZOS!
I hope ZOS do not add an AH.
I think the economy is one of the best in an MMO, we don't have crazy inflation and i personally feel like if i put in the effort i can get some really good deals that an AH would all but eliminate.
The way it works now is that there is no price point for everyone to work against meaning that people buy and sell based on what they feel the items is worth.
It also allows for more bartering which i love.
Im sorry so many of you don't like this but you can just play the game and get the items you want that way!!
Good luck!
There is no economy in eso only extortion.
Put it this way, ZOS have the user data, all of it. Sales, purchases, pricing, types if items being sold etc etc. if the numbers show it working (as I firmly believe it IS), then we'll keep it. If the numbers show it isn't working, then they'll change it eventually for the same mindless race to the bottom we have in every other mmo.