So your logic to fixing AOE abilities dealing moderate damage, to multiple targets, is to NOT punish stupid players from bunching up and getting destroyed for standing still, but to punish those who use those moderate damage dealing AOE abilities?

You good sir are the problem with modern day gamers. You want far too much for nothing ventured. Get some skill and level up a bit, try actually dodging. And just for the record, doubly punishing players by increasing spell cost while also reducing damage is why your post will be, for the most part, completely ignored, if not outright blocked from view by most peoples accounts.

firestorm_rmb16_ESO wrote: »

So your logic to fixing AOE abilities dealing moderate damage, to multiple targets, is to NOT punish stupid players from bunching up and getting destroyed for standing still, but to punish those who use those moderate damage dealing AOE abilities?

You good sir are the problem with modern day gamers. You want far too much for nothing ventured. Get some skill and level up a bit, try actually dodging. And just for the record, doubly punishing players by increasing spell cost while also reducing damage is why your post will be, for the most part, completely ignored, if not outright blocked from view by most peoples accounts.

I think that's uncalled for, and furthermore is just flame bait. AOE is probably a bit overpowered currently. Some AOEs do equal to or more damage than equivalent single-target abilities, which makes those single target abilities effectively pointless.

I don't think AOE should be both made more expensive and have it's damage nerfed, but I wouldn't necessarily disagree with one measure or the other being implemented. Some AOEs are fine - DW's whirlwind, or the sorc lightning barrage, for example. Others, like Impulse, basically render ST alternatives pointless, and so probably do need looking at.

monkeymystic wrote: »

and that you can dodge out of roots very easily.

This in particular - I've lost count of the number of times people complaining about Bat Swarm have cited the fact that they were rooted as evidence for being unable to save themselves. The game doesn't exactly flag up that you can break roots and snares very well atm.

edited, compare damage and costs of other AoE skills with Impulse

prana33b14_ESO wrote: »

Lexander wrote: »

skilled play is when u focus on key targets in the enemy zergs such as healers or glass cannon dps and take them out with CC or high damage abilities,

So how do you focus healers standing in the middle of 50+ people in this game?

also im playing mmorpg for far longer than you even know of them, son

gotabadassoverhere.jpg

after we're done nerfing the hell out of broken AoE skills we could buff some single-target abilities which should help to burst down key targets

if u are just saying that you are unable to target a specific character in a group of enemies then i feel sorry for u, maybe AoE wont be nerfed too hard so u can stay a single-button impulse badass

prana33b14_ESO wrote: »

Haha. I haven't even gotten to pvp other than in betas yet there mr. insult lobber. I'm asking how a group focus fires a healer hiding in a mob of 50 players. You know, smaller groups taking out bigger groups and stuff. I'll wait for an explanation, or more insults I guess.

if you feel insulted i should apologize then i guess, but internet is tough stuff, just so u know, mate

if u havent gotten to pvp i've no idea why i'd waste time explaining to you whats going on then, but sure i dont mind

if a group of players is as big as 50 then the nerfed but non-capped AoE should still do its job and be extremely effective in this case

the issue right now is that AoE is equally powerful if not superior to single-target abilities in a small scale pvp as well, 2 groups of 10 people would rather spam each other with Impulse to death than try to focus enemy healers or DPS using real abilities

prana33b14_ESO wrote: »

coolstorybro. That didn't answer my question. You're now avoiding it like the rubes in other thread?

Lexander wrote: »

if a group of players is as big as 50 then the nerfed but non-capped AoE should still do its job and be extremely effective in this case

your inability to make logical assumptions and follow up the idea of the sentence is growing weary on me, so plz find another thread to derail and spam with ur degradation, thx

Um, he's not a cap proponent, so your question isn't really that relevant. He's suggesting that some of the AOE abilities are rather unbalanced compared to other AOE abilities - which they really are, when you look at the pictures in his OP. I don't really see how anything else is relevant.
He's not suggesting that AOE should stop working against clumps. He's not forcing anyone to ST on a healer stood in the middle of 50 people, because a 50-man clump would still yield DPS over 5k if you halved the strength of impulse. He's suggesting that, if the healer is NOT stood in the middle of a group of 50 people, then maybe AOE should stop being the best tool for dealing with him, because ST skills should be.
I don't think that is quite as crazy as you're trying to make out, Prana. As I said before, I think nerfing damage AND increasing cost is probably an overnerf, but one or the other might be sensible in the cases he's generally pointing at.