I bought my copy of ESO from gamefly and they sent me only one code for early access. Like many of you, when I tried to log in today, I was told I needed to change my subscription, and to do that I first needed to redeem a new code. I was like, "what kittening code!" After pulling my hair out for a while a guildie suggested I got back to gamefly. That did the trick. As soon as I clicked on the link in my receipt, there were 2 new redemption codes. Any of you who bought ESO through a third party like gamefly or amazon should re-check your receipt for the new codes. Best of luck.