Maintenance for the week of October 12:
• PC/Mac: NA and EU megaservers for maintenance – October 12, 6:00AM EDT (10:00 UTC) – 8:00AM EDT (12:00 UTC)
• Xbox One: NA and EU megaservers for maintenance – October 14, 6:00AM EDT (10:00 UTC) – 9:00AM EDT (13:00 UTC)
• PlayStation®4: NA and EU megaservers for maintenance – October 14, 6:00AM EDT (10:00 UTC) – 9:00AM EDT (13:00 UTC)
The Markarth DLC and Update 28 base game patch are now available to test on the PTS! Read the full patch notes here: https://forums.elderscrollsonline.com/en/categories/pts/

Veteran content Loot / Skin / Achievement Sales problem

  • drkfrontiers
    drkfrontiers
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    I find this practice as unethical as the guy that spies on my drops during raids .. then sends me shame tells if I am going to be needing something...

    Edited by drkfrontiers on October 21, 2019 1:00PM
    "One must still have chaos in oneself to be able to give birth to a dancing star."
    ~ Friedrich Nietzsche
  • nordmarian
    nordmarian
    ✭✭✭✭
    It is also unethical to turn a threat into a personal attack towards someone, even towards OP instead of focusing ON the given facts and ON the topic.
  • LadyNalcarya
    LadyNalcarya
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    nordmarian wrote: »
    for OP. M8, u have serious problems if a video game can trigger u such. Why do u care of cyberbulling or dramas beats me completly, your life does not depend at all from it. Or maybe it does?!. Maybe u should see a therapist.

    I don't want to sound hars but maybe this one is in a wheel chair.

    What does it have to do with the whole matter ?
    When playing ESO we're all obviously sitting on chairs or sofas, wheels or not wheels.
    If, following your own declarations, you're still re-hashing and psychologically suffering from stuff that happened more than THREE YEARS AGO, and still haven't found a way over or around it, then yes, you should consider other options, including help.

    This, pretty much.
    There's no shame in seeking psychological help, especially if something is bothering you for years.
    Making the game more grindy for everyone is not going to solve OP's problems, simply because they're rooted in his relationships with other players.
    Dro-m'Athra Destroyer | Divayth Fyr's Coadjutor | Voice of Reason

    PC/EU
  • solasub
    solasub
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    . The game has enough blocking options, and there are more than enough nice guilds out there to play safely.

    yes indeed ; nice guilds kicking the player involved ; that is simple. If someone is complaining about unfair kicks, perhaps bringing some light about the real reason of kicks will avoid to spread lies and insults about "toxicity" of a community who only protected some women players after trying a lot of others solutions.

    (or do you mean that those women should have left themselves their groups to join "another nice guilds"? so the harassed are the ones who need to leave? That is a quite strange point of view)
    Edited by solasub on October 21, 2019 2:03PM
    Tick Tock Tormentor• Gryphon Heart • Immortal Redeemer • Extinguisher of Flames • Dro-m'Athra Destroyer • Shiel of the North
    PVP Alpha Squad
    PVE : SacreBleu Guild leader



  • anitajoneb17_ESO
    anitajoneb17_ESO
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    solasub wrote: »
    (or do you mean that those women should have left themselves their groups to join "another nice guilds"? so the harassed are the ones who need to leave? That is a quite strange point of view)

    No, what I'm saying is that IF you had not stepped up to clear the situation yourself as a GM, those players still could have and should have left for warmer sands.
    I believe you did the right thing, but many GMs aren't any good at managing people or dealing with groups, would accuse the victims of being the troublemakers, priviledge their friends over any sense of justice, whatever. There are many reasons why a GM would not step up in such situations, and in such a case, the victims are still free to leave. Sure, it sounds unfair that "victims have to leave" but looking at the bigger picture, they'll be better off in a guild with a GM like you than with a GM that does nothing in such situations.

    Noone is ever stuck in a harassment situation in a video game like they can be in real life with a job, a harassing colleague, a spouse who's become violent, stuff like that. I'm not minimizing what people may experience in an online gaming community, but imo comparing it to real harassment is actually minimizing real harassment situations where the victims are truly helpless. Noone is helpless in ESO, there's an easy way out. That's what I meant.
    Edited by anitajoneb17_ESO on October 21, 2019 2:29PM
  • hasi
    hasi
    ✭✭✭✭
    Dusk_Coven wrote: »
    hasi wrote: »
    Dusk_Coven wrote: »
    I think it's really interesting that more people aren't upset by these title-and-loot selling runs. Basically people are trading gold for a title or special loot, right?

    But if ZOS put those special loots in the Crown Store and made them giftable (so there's a way to get them through gold), I think there'd be complaints.
    If they put the TITLEs in the Crown Store the forum would have a meltdown. And yet players are basically doing it.

    Because Crown Store is straight up available to everyone. Someone, who just started the Game, could easily buy said Skin or Title etc. They'd lose in value by A LOT.

    Also, why would anyone run Trials/Dungeons if they can simply straight up buy the Skin or whatever? At least now you need a good group, a group that put efforts in to be able to carry others.

    I dunno. A purchase is still a purchase. Still sounds like a double-standard against ZOS, maybe because people don't like to see ZOS making money. It'd be like Maelstrom style pages -- either get them yourself, buy them off players (similar to getting a carry), or buy them from ZOS.

    If you mean a title would lose MEANING yes for sure buying it would lose meaning. But that's what players are doing now.

    Players buying Titles makes them lose meaning, yes, indeed. But having a handful of People being able to buy something via Gold and the possibility of everyone being able to buy every title/skin via Money/Crowns. There is quite a measure difference.
    Edited by hasi on October 21, 2019 2:37PM
  • CaffeinatedMayhem
    CaffeinatedMayhem
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭
    Paid carries are crap to me. I will never pay for an achivement carry, and don't allow it in groups I lead. However, ZOS will never be able to stamp out the problem. From the game's standpoint, you "earned" that titlte, even if you just subbed in on the last boss.

    My issue with the raiding community is what you describe: toxicity. Some players get lucky and have someone teach them content, and stay in core groups. Others can't even get in if they are good, because of "reasons." (not L2P) I'm starting my own trials group (again) because the small raiding community here is overall, very toxic.

    In before "well here's my story of how I was a complete noob and someone took me in"... that's great for you. Not everyone gets that chance. Even when we've been playing for 5 years.
  • Dusk_Coven
    Dusk_Coven
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭
    hasi wrote: »
    Dusk_Coven wrote: »
    It'd be like Maelstrom style pages -- either get them yourself, buy them off players (similar to getting a carry), or buy them from ZOS.

    Players buying Titles makes them lose meaning, yes, indeed. But having a handful of People being able to buy something via Gold and the possibility of everyone being able to buy every title/skin via Money/Crowns. There is quite a measure difference.

    ZOS hasn't sold titles yet, so that's moot for now. But Maelstrom style pages -- they are fine for ZOS to sell but skins from trials are not? Is that splitting hairs? Someone had to spend at least an hour of their life to grind out that one page but ZOS was selling them in the event store, which also basically means they were Crown-purchasable.
    As for difficulty --if someone could grind out a bunch of Maelstrom pages, it means it was easy enough for them. Same as for these vet trial groups: It'd have to be basically a sure thing that came from doing it over and over.

    In both cases, it's people unwilling or unable to do the content but wanting the same rewards. And in one case we let ZOS sell the rewards but we're gonna be upset if we let them do the other?

    As for Titles -- is wearing a Maelstrom style you didn't personally earn not like wearing a title you didn't personally earn?

    Still seems like ZOS is getting the double standard treatment based on precedents.
    Edited by Dusk_Coven on October 21, 2019 3:14PM
  • hasi
    hasi
    ✭✭✭✭
    Dusk_Coven wrote: »
    hasi wrote: »
    Dusk_Coven wrote: »
    It'd be like Maelstrom style pages -- either get them yourself, buy them off players (similar to getting a carry), or buy them from ZOS.

    Players buying Titles makes them lose meaning, yes, indeed. But having a handful of People being able to buy something via Gold and the possibility of everyone being able to buy every title/skin via Money/Crowns. There is quite a measure difference.

    ZOS hasn't sold titles yet, so that's moot for now. But Maelstrom style pages -- they are fine for ZOS to sell but skins from trials are not? Is that splitting hairs? Someone had to spend at least an hour of their life to grind out that one page but ZOS was selling them in the event store, which also basically means they were Crown-purchasable.
    As for difficulty --if someone could grind out a bunch of Maelstrom pages, it means it was easy enough for them. Same as for these vet trial groups: It'd have to be basically a sure thing that came from doing it over and over.

    In both cases, it's people unwilling or unable to do the content but wanting the same rewards. And in one case we let ZOS sell the rewards but we're gonna be upset if we let them do the other?

    As for Titles -- is wearing a Maelstrom style you didn't personally earn not like wearing a title you didn't personally earn?

    Still seems like ZOS is getting the double standard treatment based on precedents.

    Maelstrom Style Pages wouldn't be the first, you know. Raid Motifs or Overland Motifs(from Dailies for example) are sold in the Crown Store too while being available ingame.

    Also, I don't understand your arguments. A motif doesn't have the worth of a Skin or a Title. You are putting Trial Achievments, where People had to coordinate themselves for, communicate, practice for Ages, against Motifs, that you could earn via Event Activities.

    And there were several Event Activities to get Maelstrom Style Pages, not just the one you limited them to.
  • CaffeinatedMayhem
    CaffeinatedMayhem
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭


    5) I do these runs for guildies without charging them.

    *spits out coffee* Then what do you call advertising your PAID runs in guild chat and Discord??? Only once have you said "I won't charge you guys" - in a private Discord channel, that most of the guild doesn't see. You also charge guildies for bites. I've seen you do it.
    Edited by CaffeinatedMayhem on October 21, 2019 4:12PM
  • Jem_Kindheart
    Jem_Kindheart
    ✭✭✭
    Heck, my guildies have a couple teams I'm on, we've gotten vSS and vMoL down to where we can bring in random guildies in for their very first time ever in those trials and get them cleared, sometimes two at a time. We wouldn't dream of charging guildies for that, and the road to get there was long and expensive lol. I think I spent 14 weeks trying to clear vSS the first time oof. Hodor would roll his eyes at that lol. The previous team spent months on vMoL. Not everyone has that time or will, or ability idk. Now, if someone else is just in the right place at the right time, and gets the clear without spending the time I or others did, I don't really care. It doesn't detract from me. If someone pays some other guild for it, idc either. Doesn't affect me and it's not my business.

    There's tons of reasons, we have disabled players who maybe want the skin to look cool. Idk, I think most skins are uuuuuugly. Some are just roleplayers, fine. There's tons of reasons to buy runs.

    I don't think it's unethical, but then again I can do the content. Buying runs at this point would just be to save time. In other people's cases, it's still not going to make a mediocre player suddenly amazing. That 1000 extra mag/stam from perfected is kinda big meh.
    Longtimer since beta, the usual. 20 CP toons. 810+ on main account, 400cp on 2nd account. Endgame-ish lol. Healer main: vSS, vSO HM, vAA HM, vAS+2, vMoL, vHoF, vHRC, vDSA. DPS NB: most things in game+Flawless. USMC 00-08 Hoorah
  • St_Anger
    St_Anger
    ✭✭✭
    nordmarian wrote: »
    - People who earned some achievements fair cannot be distinguished anymore from people who bought their ways towards top.

    This can be a real problem in endgame raiding. If someone has no clue/dps it is pretty easy to see that they bought it, but often it is much harder to realize, because the people are not bad per se, but just not good enaugh to clear this content. So often it takes weeks or months until it is clear, that this person did not work their way through it and is just not good enaugh for the group they just joined.

    But I don't share most of your experience, and to be honest, it sounds like you were mostly playing with a bunch of purpose community guys instead of friends.
  • Elwendryll
    Elwendryll
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    Too specific options. I start reading some of them "This might be ok" and then it ends by "It should stop".

    Your poll is biased because it heavily express your opinion.

    Now, I think these practices are a bit shady. Whenever I see an advertisement in chat I feel a bit of disapproval. But, other than that, the disapproval is not toward the people selling the run. They are skilled enough to pull that off, they can do whatever they want.

    I do, on the other hand, find it a bit dishonest to buy runs, because it's knowingly devaluing a reward by getting it without any form of merit. But I can totally understand people who would do that. The rewards are very cool, and not everyone has the skill or time to progress.

    I think this practice is totally okay as long as all parties are willingly taking part in the exchange and there is no scam.

    By the look of it, you were with a very toxic team. I don't have any similar experience and I have no idea how widespread this kind of mindset can be.

    There is one thing I 100% agree on. The difficulty/length to reward ratio is not satisfying. The old trials lack perfected gears, and there is no real incentive to go farm let's say vHoF when you can get better AND perfected gear by just running vSS.
    Edited by Elwendryll on October 21, 2019 10:52PM
    PC - EU - France - AD
    Main character: Qojikrin (Previously Jah'Kar) : Khajiit Stamina Sorcerer - since March 25, 2015.
    Guildmaster of Oriflamme: Focus on 4 players endgame content.
    Member of Brave Cat Trade and Scions of Dawn.

  • nordmarian
    nordmarian
    ✭✭✭✭
    Are you for real?
    Honestly, I will keep myself out of further "personal" discussions like I did before, BUT you sound EXACTLY like my first ESO friend.

    A man, who was 10 years older than I was, with me being underage. We came along pretty well at the start, until he decided to start arguments over my Playstyle etc. on a daily basis, later on adding insults, based on my origin and gender. :)

    When I decided to leave him, he claimed that I had used him, stolen his stuff. He was salty and needy.
    In private he created fake Accounts though, so he could text me, beg for ...............

    Sorry to hear that. I did wanted to say that some people, girls or even guys pretending to be girls, got close to me and tried to trick me into giving them favors. Gold carries etc. If i was neutral or distanced myself they threatened me or talked me or simply ignored me. Same if they get what they wanted they put you behind and then call you names.

    Also please keep in mind that in an argument there are always multiple sides of the story. The parties involved ones and the outsiders. Most people i dealt with only hear one side of the story and stop there and judge. They dont bother hearing all parties involved. Nor the whole story.

    Also keep in mind that some people accousing me are not entirely innocent in this. They were right i might did something bad but they also served me injustice. For ex. Being removed from a team u like after months of progression in vhof and vmol just day before they cleared it then bragging in my face wasnt mature. That came due to player skills. Leading communication. Attitude. And honezt mistakest. I did overreact but also appologized.
    On short blames in team which werent constructive lead to a fight and when approached some people from the team to hear their side thy became ignorant, took sides or stated harassment.
    After hundreds of pugging vmol you do tend to become lazy or not play corectly a hardmode mechanic. Being told but not shown isnt constructive.

    And there is also a very sad outcome about this story which we dont want to talk about. But it did impacted my reputation very bad.
    Nothing personal. To those accusing me.

    And yes some conflicts can easily being avoided if all parties involved can work together for a sollution but as i said in one previous post some gm instead of preventing a fight from happening they ignored the facts and then attacked me and went further and banned me from guilds we didnt even shared but were allied.
    Edited by nordmarian on October 22, 2019 12:48AM
  • nordmarian
    nordmarian
    ✭✭✭✭
    All i did was to point out towards some flaws and people pointed out quick towards my attitude or reputation or skills. I would like to talk about that. And those directly involved in a fight with me, i have no one on my block list and i really dont mind putting that behind. Why you? Those who heard stories same. If not for me or you do it for those innocents caught in between. Peace.
  • LadyNalcarya
    LadyNalcarya
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    nordmarian wrote: »
    And there is also a very sad outcome about this story which we dont want to talk about. But it did impacted my reputation very bad.
    Nothing personal. To those accusing me.

    And yes some conflicts can easily being avoided if all parties involved can work together for a sollution but as i said in one previous post some gm instead of preventing a fight from happening they ignored the facts and then attacked me and went further and banned me from guilds we didnt even shared but were allied.

    Well, the whole topic is about your troubled relationships with your guild/guilds. All of this has very little to do with selling carry runs. Even if ZOS would start banning for that, those guilds still won't invite you back, right?
    The best you can do is to move on and try to avoid making the same mistakes. And if really bothers you, try talking to a psychologist. I don't mean it as an insult of something, this could really help. The current situation is just bad, regardless of who's right and who's wrong: living in the past won't make it any better.
    Dro-m'Athra Destroyer | Divayth Fyr's Coadjutor | Voice of Reason

    PC/EU
  • nordmarian
    nordmarian
    ✭✭✭✭
    Lets just go to the first post there where I did stated some problems... I don't mind if people sell carries or not but I do mind if those few individuals (not everyone) are creating drama towards others in the therm of not playing together anymore. I gave few facts. Others also tried to complete with. I am well aware that there are 10k guilds out there you can choose for but that is not the subject of this topic however.

    Can you guys agree that paid carry runs for various reasons also got a lot of undesirable effects? Letting aside the advantage of helping others such as pvp players for example. Thanks.
  • nordmarian
    nordmarian
    ✭✭✭✭
    @MyPrist if you have something to say go ahead i dont mind.
  • MyPrist
    MyPrist
    ✭✭✭
    nordmarian wrote: »
    @MyPrist if you have something to say go ahead i dont mind.

    I think that there is no dlc hm dunguan, exept frost vault, that can not easely be done, by only 2 people. So selling or not selling some thing from paid run is not a big problem. I am not on that level to close hm fang lair solo for example, but i saw how people do that. But i can do it easely with two of our team i play with. Like all dunguan in game.

    I tank all veteran dlc dunguon on dd, i tank all of that on tank on hm. So this content is not really hard. And there were even those, who played better than me and do it solo.

    Who do not let you try it? They did it, are others so bad, that they can not learn how to do it? I think that they do not.

    A lot of players like this like to play random dunguans, and only dlc.
    Do you know why ? Becouse it is much harder, than make it with statick group. And if it is harder people can upgrade their skills and play even better untill they can solo it.

    If you play it often enough it is not problem to close any of 4 players skin or achivment.

    But you will be kicked from there group as soon as :
    1) You try to kick any 1 other member from party, for no reason.
    2) You ask some other player play like you like if they do not. Alkosh for tank ? Ok no problem. Go tank in alkosh i will go on my dd than ?
    What a problem ? Have no tank ? By by than. I want to finish dunguan with fun, not do some freak wants me to do with no reason giving me nothing for it.
    3) You learn others what to do, if they do not ask your opinion.

    I know a lot of players like this, not enough but they are.
    They do veteran dlc naked, do not look alcast. "Alcast ? What ? Who is it? Do not say me any tacticks, i do not want spoilers, i want and i can do it myself. I do not need spoilers ! " - it is like reading book or tv show for them.

    And they L2P and become better and better.

    But for some people here L2P is something rood and bad.

    May be it is, if you play really bad and want do nothing. May be it it is not, if you really try to learn.

    The same for trials, a lot if them can easely be made by 8 people.

    If you are not toxick, try do yor best - what is the problem than?

    Not all people play well. If they learn it is not a problem, if they do not - than they take place of some one that can, and it is no place for them.

    It is not metter are you better then some one or not.

    Are you better today then you were yesterday. Only this thing metters.

    If you do not learn, if you are toxic - people will not play with you.

    If you play really bad and try, it us funny to play with you - thouse who can do instance solo will help some day even if you can not do it yourself one day.

    But if you do not try = do not get.

    What is a problem to buy anything from trial or dlc dunguon if you do not like that content? No problem

    I and a lot of players do it not becouse of it. It is just fun !

    Some times harder with random groups but even more fun. If they are not toxic.

    If they are - they better buy and i hope i will never see them in party again.
  • Sinolai
    Sinolai
    ✭✭✭✭✭
    I like raids being different in length and in my opinion vHoF is the best raid in this game. You can do vHoF if you have that time or if you dont you can go to cloudrest instead.
    I have run in a few "carry sales runs" myself too but I don't really recognize any of the problems you listed, apart from "It is unfair to profit from players less experienced or with less time available". I do feel a light sting on my chest, especially when I notice the carry is not that bad player but he just lacks a team that is on the same level with him.

    Regardless, in the group where I have been running, money has always been shared equally, though organizer gets a small bonus (and I think that is fair). Getting paid for doing a raid is nice but despite that most of us still also play in some progressive group. Those who dont are the people who already cleared everything in their own progressive groups and now only join occasionally for their own enjoyment. In my experience, you can never avoid drama and there is always someone who you don't like or who don't like you in the team but if you can tolerate each others for 2-3 hours a couple of times a week everything will go fine. True that raiding too much sometimes result to burn out but that has happened to me and many others even when we didn't do carries - and yet, we still play this game.
  • nordmarian
    nordmarian
    ✭✭✭✭
    Do you know why ? Becouse it is much harder, than make it with statick group. And if it is harder people can upgrade their skills and play even better untill they can solo it.

    Doing content without being part of a static group is one problem I encountered way too often lately. What does it stop someone to simply join a group of friends and help them out? Or even zone. Pointing out towards I can earn x gold in 30 min is just wrong.
    People no longer enjoying helping out of their hearts. I did cleared pretty much all content with few exceptions but If people ask my help even with some training runs in nHOF or vMOL If I'm free, I'm there.
    Leaving a group only because someone invited you to another content during same time is also something I don't enjoy being part or caught off. Might have done it as well but at least I did excused myself or even tried to find a replacement.
    Leaving a group after 1 2 or 3 wipes is also very impolite and toxic behavior.

    We both agree that I am not talking about everyone, but those few individuals whom are being less friendly towards others are also dragging down others.

    Often I called some well known and experienced guildies to help out with some training runs for example. Why they didn't helped their own guild mates? L2P? I agree someone isn't too skilled, point out in the right direction them, even if they don't ask for your opinion. Making fun of them is just so wrong.
    Edited by nordmarian on October 23, 2019 4:08AM
Sign In or Register to comment.