Yes, normal dummies makes comparison to live a lot easier...
Olupajmibanan wrote: »Yes, normal dummies makes comparison to live a lot easier...
The Raid dummy is made for class and setup comparison.
I don't know if OP's intent is to compare classes between each other, or compare PTS dps with live DPS. He posted Raid dummy DPS, so I guess he wants to see class comparisons.
Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
Colecovision wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
Did your nightblade and necro have the same amount of health when you tested?
Colecovision wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
Did your nightblade and necro have the same amount of health when you tested?
We lost some HP with Atreum. Like 500 or so.
Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
MassTerror23 wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
To better compare the stam necro and stamblade don’t use tooth for the necro because I doubt that set will be meta
MassTerror23 wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
To better compare the stam necro and stamblade don’t use tooth for the necro because I doubt that set will be meta
MassTerror23 wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
To better compare the stam necro and stamblade don’t use tooth for the necro because I doubt that set will be meta
MassTerror23 wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
To better compare the stam necro and stamblade don’t use tooth for the necro because I doubt that set will be meta
Im curious about the reasoning about tooth not being meta because unless im missing something that set will provide close to 100% major slayer uptime and should be better than basically anything else other than relequen.
MassTerror23 wrote: »MassTerror23 wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
To better compare the stam necro and stamblade don’t use tooth for the necro because I doubt that set will be meta
Im curious about the reasoning about tooth not being meta because unless im missing something that set will provide close to 100% major slayer uptime and should be better than basically anything else other than relequen.
What about the mag toons in group? If it’s 4 stam and 4 mag and the stam are all using tooth then two mag have to wear MA but then there’s no guarantee that the stam won’t steal the MA major slayer from the mag during the time tooth isn’t active.
MassTerror23 wrote: »MassTerror23 wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
To better compare the stam necro and stamblade don’t use tooth for the necro because I doubt that set will be meta
Im curious about the reasoning about tooth not being meta because unless im missing something that set will provide close to 100% major slayer uptime and should be better than basically anything else other than relequen.
What about the mag toons in group? If it’s 4 stam and 4 mag and the stam are all using tooth then two mag have to wear MA but then there’s no guarantee that the stam won’t steal the MA major slayer from the mag during the time tooth isn’t active.
Mag toons will use selfish sets in this case, like siroria, spell strategist, mother sorrow, the new vicious ophidian for magicka set... 100% major slayer is too good to pass. And you are assuming that magnb or magwardens (master arquitect users) will be meta dps, thing that i doubt, I see magnecros, magsorcs and maplars stronger.
MassTerror23 wrote: »MassTerror23 wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
To better compare the stam necro and stamblade don’t use tooth for the necro because I doubt that set will be meta
Im curious about the reasoning about tooth not being meta because unless im missing something that set will provide close to 100% major slayer uptime and should be better than basically anything else other than relequen.
What about the mag toons in group? If it’s 4 stam and 4 mag and the stam are all using tooth then two mag have to wear MA but then there’s no guarantee that the stam won’t steal the MA major slayer from the mag during the time tooth isn’t active. Another thing is I’m a console player and from what I heard is that the iron-atro parses won’t be accepted so 3 mil and 6 mil parses with tooth won’t be possible.
LiquidPony wrote: »MassTerror23 wrote: »MassTerror23 wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
To better compare the stam necro and stamblade don’t use tooth for the necro because I doubt that set will be meta
Im curious about the reasoning about tooth not being meta because unless im missing something that set will provide close to 100% major slayer uptime and should be better than basically anything else other than relequen.
What about the mag toons in group? If it’s 4 stam and 4 mag and the stam are all using tooth then two mag have to wear MA but then there’s no guarantee that the stam won’t steal the MA major slayer from the mag during the time tooth isn’t active. Another thing is I’m a console player and from what I heard is that the iron-atro parses won’t be accepted so 3 mil and 6 mil parses with tooth won’t be possible.
What people "accept" for solo DPS parses in no way reflects the meta for real raids.
And why wouldn't console players accept parses from the raid dummy? It dramatically simplifies the parsing process because everyone has a uniform set of buffs, debuffs, and uptimes to deal with. This should be especially pertinent to console players since you have no way of tracking buff/debuff uptimes in-game.
And anyway, if you're worried about people in Tooth of Lokke "stealing" Major Slayer from magicka toons, then put them in different stacks like we already do.
MassTerror23 wrote: »LiquidPony wrote: »MassTerror23 wrote: »MassTerror23 wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
To better compare the stam necro and stamblade don’t use tooth for the necro because I doubt that set will be meta
Im curious about the reasoning about tooth not being meta because unless im missing something that set will provide close to 100% major slayer uptime and should be better than basically anything else other than relequen.
What about the mag toons in group? If it’s 4 stam and 4 mag and the stam are all using tooth then two mag have to wear MA but then there’s no guarantee that the stam won’t steal the MA major slayer from the mag during the time tooth isn’t active. Another thing is I’m a console player and from what I heard is that the iron-atro parses won’t be accepted so 3 mil and 6 mil parses with tooth won’t be possible.
What people "accept" for solo DPS parses in no way reflects the meta for real raids.
And why wouldn't console players accept parses from the raid dummy? It dramatically simplifies the parsing process because everyone has a uniform set of buffs, debuffs, and uptimes to deal with. This should be especially pertinent to console players since you have no way of tracking buff/debuff uptimes in-game.
And anyway, if you're worried about people in Tooth of Lokke "stealing" Major Slayer from magicka toons, then put them in different stacks like we already do.
Some the reasons that were mentioned was that buffs like hircine and worm aren’t something given in trials (the guilds I’m in don’t run worm), major force uptime being 100% is a little far fetched and it doesn’t have minor magic steal. But I 100% agree that it does help better compare parses.
MassTerror23 wrote: »LiquidPony wrote: »MassTerror23 wrote: »MassTerror23 wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
To better compare the stam necro and stamblade don’t use tooth for the necro because I doubt that set will be meta
Im curious about the reasoning about tooth not being meta because unless im missing something that set will provide close to 100% major slayer uptime and should be better than basically anything else other than relequen.
What about the mag toons in group? If it’s 4 stam and 4 mag and the stam are all using tooth then two mag have to wear MA but then there’s no guarantee that the stam won’t steal the MA major slayer from the mag during the time tooth isn’t active. Another thing is I’m a console player and from what I heard is that the iron-atro parses won’t be accepted so 3 mil and 6 mil parses with tooth won’t be possible.
What people "accept" for solo DPS parses in no way reflects the meta for real raids.
And why wouldn't console players accept parses from the raid dummy? It dramatically simplifies the parsing process because everyone has a uniform set of buffs, debuffs, and uptimes to deal with. This should be especially pertinent to console players since you have no way of tracking buff/debuff uptimes in-game.
And anyway, if you're worried about people in Tooth of Lokke "stealing" Major Slayer from magicka toons, then put them in different stacks like we already do.
Some the reasons that were mentioned was that buffs like hircine and worm aren’t something given in trials (the guilds I’m in don’t run worm), major force uptime being 100% is a little far fetched and it doesn’t have minor magic steal. But I 100% agree that it does help better compare parses.
MassTerror23 wrote: »LiquidPony wrote: »MassTerror23 wrote: »MassTerror23 wrote: »Curious - I personally am speaking from a stam perspective .
Playing a Khajiit sNecro/sBlade on the new dummy I have found the following -
Necro - Relequen/Tooth : 85-90k ish DPS.
Blade - Relequen/AY : 85k ish DPS
Necro still seems pretty strong compared to blade, but I also haven't done any test with whirling blades ( I assume that won't make it to live as is as it seems kinda powerful ).
I think sBlade for a PVE standpoint is pretty good still. I'd like to see where Warden falls now though, which will be my next and probably last test as I do not play Plar, DK or Sorc.
Anyone else have any thoughts? Many still think Nightblade is gutted and I don't think that is quite true.
To better compare the stam necro and stamblade don’t use tooth for the necro because I doubt that set will be meta
Im curious about the reasoning about tooth not being meta because unless im missing something that set will provide close to 100% major slayer uptime and should be better than basically anything else other than relequen.
What about the mag toons in group? If it’s 4 stam and 4 mag and the stam are all using tooth then two mag have to wear MA but then there’s no guarantee that the stam won’t steal the MA major slayer from the mag during the time tooth isn’t active. Another thing is I’m a console player and from what I heard is that the iron-atro parses won’t be accepted so 3 mil and 6 mil parses with tooth won’t be possible.
What people "accept" for solo DPS parses in no way reflects the meta for real raids.
And why wouldn't console players accept parses from the raid dummy? It dramatically simplifies the parsing process because everyone has a uniform set of buffs, debuffs, and uptimes to deal with. This should be especially pertinent to console players since you have no way of tracking buff/debuff uptimes in-game.
And anyway, if you're worried about people in Tooth of Lokke "stealing" Major Slayer from magicka toons, then put them in different stacks like we already do.
Some the reasons that were mentioned was that buffs like hircine and worm aren’t something given in trials (the guilds I’m in don’t run worm), major force uptime being 100% is a little far fetched and it doesn’t have minor magic steal. But I 100% agree that it does help better compare parses.
Sure it's not realistic, but its all about comparative numbers. Dealing 21m damage in a fight is never going to happen either, and the resource drain you see on that dummy fight is likely to be lower in real fights where there is down time for dealing with mechanics.
I see a lot of console players parsing on 3m dummies on YT so maybe their idea of what's acceptable is lagging behind PC?
You have perfect support and perfect buffs on the 21m. If you're running out of resources you need more sustain.
If you're running "parse food" on the 21m you're cheesing. Use your actual trial setup.
From what I've seen 45kish will do around 70k on the iron golem. 50k 6mil parses should be in the area of 80k.
I'm finding very little variance in parses and changing setups etc will have demonstrable changes.
It's really really good.
As soon as this thing goes live all parses should be done on it. The only downside right now is cmx isn't picking up the buffs etc from the dummy.
LiquidPony wrote: »You have perfect support and perfect buffs on the 21m. If you're running out of resources you need more sustain.
If you're running "parse food" on the 21m you're cheesing. Use your actual trial setup.
From what I've seen 45kish will do around 70k on the iron golem. 50k 6mil parses should be in the area of 80k.
I'm finding very little variance in parses and changing setups etc will have demonstrable changes.
It's really really good.
As soon as this thing goes live all parses should be done on it. The only downside right now is cmx isn't picking up the buffs etc from the dummy.
Not really realistic to think that you should be parsing a 21m with your normal raid setup IMO. There aren't many fights in the game where you are parsing on a single target without pause for 3.5-4.5 minutes straight. The 21m dummy fight is simply too long for that. If it had maybe 15m health, it might be more realistic to parse with gold food but at 21m, no way.
Plus, you're missing out on all of the additional synergies and other sources of sustain like Sentinel of Rkugamz and Symphony of Blades.
I doubt there's any stam spec that can solo parse a 21m without Lavafoot on an Orc/Khajiit/Dunmer. But those same builds have no problem sustaining real fights. Hell, on an Orc stamnecro, it's hard enough to sustain the 21m with Lavafoot food. Even in Liko's 104k parse (with the bugged pets) he was on empty as the dummy was dying.