So you are telling me....

Narvuntien

If you group up for a random normal.... go into the dungeon.
One member of your group declares they are going to FG1, You just don't care because you are cp810 and all normal dungeons are easy and you go on to 3 man the dungeon (this case FGII) but if they complete their solo of FG1 before your group of three does FGII you don't get any rewards????

How is that even close to fair??

edit: I was crown

John_Falstaff

@Narvuntien , well, the group is doing something that exploits a bug, and never was meant to be happening in first place. What did you expect? When you're using any sort of undocumented feature, all bets are off. If group decided to stay, then kick the person who went to FG1 (after making sure that it can't be resolved by, well... talking to them).

Sparr0w

If someone ports out... there's a kick feature...

Merlin13KAGL

It's not fair. It's not in the intended design in the first place to be in two separate dungeons at the same time.

It's an edge case that frankly shouldn't have to be checked for.

You should've kicked and found a replacement and this would be a non-issue.

There's also already a half a dozen threads on this sort of thing already.

EDIT: In three more hours, it will no longer be an issue anyway.

Gatviper

Kick that one group member. Why keep in group if he doesn't contribute.

swippy

you forgot to kick someone who bailed on you? whoops...

Narvuntien

We didn't both to kick because we just jumped right into the dungeon and were busy completing the dungeon.
Once I realised, I thought he would fail to solo FG1 or that we would both get rewards... we both completed a dungeon.
Plus kicking him will put him onto another group and someone else would have to deal with him.

The system just seems stupidly broken that the 1 gets the rewards and not the 3? or that anyone can jump to fg1 in the first place or that one person can even solo a dungeon (faster than 3 can do another) there are a million things wrong with the game systems here there systems are still around after the event.

SpacemanSpiff1

He should have asked first instead of just porting. Bummer you didn't get a chance to kick him. i don't know why those people don't just make their own group before queuing.

Aebaradath

SpacemanSpiff1 wrote: »

He should have asked first instead of just porting. Bummer you didn't get a chance to kick him. i don't know why those people don't just make their own group before queuing.

They think they're too important to ask and believe people should just conform and take the shortcut within a shortcut.

Katahdin

That's an interesting twist.
He soloed and finished FG1 before your 3 man finished FG2 and you got no reward box for the completion of FG2?

Weird

protofeckless

FWIW, he got the rewards because he was crown, not because he finished first. If crown was with you then the guy that left wouldn't have gotten the rewards.

You should have kicked him or joined him.

Zypheran

Edit: Sorry, I miss-read your post. I see now that somebody else did the exploit and your dungeon run got ruined because of it. Well, that is totally unfair and should be sorted

Katahdin

Zypheran wrote: »

Edit: Sorry, I miss-read your post. I see now that somebody else did the exploit and your dungeon run got ruined because of it. Well, that is totally unfair and should be sorted

Read the OP again. The guy that jumped dungeons got the box, the 3 that stayed did not

Streega

protofeckless wrote: »

FWIW, he got the rewards because he was crown, not because he finished first. If crown was with you then the guy that left wouldn't have gotten the rewards.

You should have kicked him or joined him.

That's not true, we had group of 3 guildies + 1 random, the random ported without a word to FG1; We stayed and did FH, but by the time we finished, he was long done with FG1; He was NOT the crown, yet we didn't get any reward (no box, no Undaunted stuff). WHY? We did "proper", harder dungeon, but HE got the rewards only because he finished first!
Now, I'm not a saint and I did port to FG couple of times when we had a weak group and got DLC dungeon, but ONLY when all group members agreed. In the case mentioned above one of guys wanted to do FH, so we stayed and did it with only 3 ppl. Shame we didn't kick the random, but we didn't realise he will "steal" our rewards