Delete bad players, please.

Vimora

Did someone say delete WGT? Ok, this gave me an idea. How about deleting bad players? Let's say the worst 5% players every month that is calculated based on dps vs. dungeon and raid bosses.

Most importantly,

1. this only applies to players that enter dungeons and raids, so the casual overland player is not affected,
2. this only applies to players over CP300, so new players (and I think we are being generous here) are not affected.

So what happens to the tourist that just wants to experience the story of a dungeon or raid without contributing in any meaningful way? There should be an option for the party leader to mark a player as "tourist," which allows this player to be exempt from any dps obligations, thus protecting them from deletion based on the run.

Obviously, healers and tanks are not affected by this, only damage dealers.

Rouven

Vimora wrote: »

(...)

Obviously, healers and tanks are not affected by this, only damage dealers.

To clarify, there are no bad players that play as tanks or healers?

SirAndy

Vimora wrote: »

How about deleting bad players?

Well, goodbye then, sorry you couldn't make the cut.

idk

Vimora wrote: »

Did someone say delete WGT? Ok, this gave me an idea. How about deleting bad players? Let's say the worst 5% players every month that is calculated based on dps vs. dungeon and raid bosses.

Obviously, healers and tanks are not affected by this, only damage dealers.

So, eventually we have a bunch of tanks and at least half of them bad with only the top 10-20% of the DPS remaining. So, if you cannot pull, maybe, 35k DPS on a test dummy you are outa here. May take a few months but it will be coming.

OP is might just be a tank or healer and does not want to worry about being cut.

Really seems short sighted. Granted, OP is probably not serious, but still, an absurd idea to post.

DeadlyRecluse

This is some low effort trolling.

Subversus

What if I don't do pve and only duel/BGs? Do I also get deleted?

idk

Subversus wrote: »

What if I don't do pve and only duel/BGs? Do I also get deleted?

Sure, why not. Cya

jlboozer

You're some sort of master at baiting....will probably catch a few!

Vimora

Rouven wrote: »

Vimora wrote: »

(...)

Obviously, healers and tanks are not affected by this, only damage dealers.

To clarify, there are no bad players that play as tanks or healers?

Yes, there are, but they tend to be kicked if the party can't do the run, so they stop doing that.

stewhead2ub17_ESO

Nothing to see here. Move along.

Dark_Lord_Kuro

Vimora wrote: »

Did someone say delete WGT? Ok, this gave me an idea. How about deleting bad players? Let's say the worst 5% players every month that is calculated based on dps vs. dungeon and raid bosses.

Most importantly,

1. this only applies to players that enter dungeons and raids, so the casual overland player is not affected,
2. this only applies to players over CP300, so new players (and I think we are being generous here) are not affected.

So what happens to the tourist that just wants to experience the story of a dungeon or raid without contributing in any meaningful way? There should be an option for the party leader to mark a player as "tourist," which allows this player to be exempt from any dps obligations, thus protecting them from deletion based on the run.

Obviously, healers and tanks are not affected by this, only damage dealers.

Wow
How about deleting stupid player aswell?

eso_nya

What happens to ppl who solo dungeons? Do you get deletd because u r the worst dd in the run?

Vimora

idk wrote: »

Vimora wrote: »

Did someone say delete WGT? Ok, this gave me an idea. How about deleting bad players? Let's say the worst 5% players every month that is calculated based on dps vs. dungeon and raid bosses.

Obviously, healers and tanks are not affected by this, only damage dealers.

So, eventually we have a bunch of tanks and at least half of them bad with only the top 10-20% of the DPS remaining. So, if you cannot pull, maybe, 35k DPS on a test dummy you are outa here. May take a few months but it will be coming.

OP is might just be a tank or healer and does not want to worry about being cut.

Really seems short sighted. Granted, OP is probably not serious, but still, an absurd idea to post.

It sounds absurd. But think about it. We are talking CP300+ damage dealers, who couldn't be bothered to l2p in the probably 300+ random dungeons that you can run before reaching this CP level. While they are ruining 3 other players' experience. So I get it, I might sound evil on the surface but is this really that unreasonable?

OC_Justice

Dark_Lord_Kuro wrote: »

Vimora wrote: »

Did someone say delete WGT? Ok, this gave me an idea. How about deleting bad players? Let's say the worst 5% players every month that is calculated based on dps vs. dungeon and raid bosses.

Most importantly,

1. this only applies to players that enter dungeons and raids, so the casual overland player is not affected,
2. this only applies to players over CP300, so new players (and I think we are being generous here) are not affected.

So what happens to the tourist that just wants to experience the story of a dungeon or raid without contributing in any meaningful way? There should be an option for the party leader to mark a player as "tourist," which allows this player to be exempt from any dps obligations, thus protecting them from deletion based on the run.

Obviously, healers and tanks are not affected by this, only damage dealers.

Wow
How about deleting stupid player aswell?

Scratching my head here. You mean delete stupid forum trolls?

Vimora

OC_Justice wrote: »

Dark_Lord_Kuro wrote: »

Vimora wrote: »

Did someone say delete WGT? Ok, this gave me an idea. How about deleting bad players? Let's say the worst 5% players every month that is calculated based on dps vs. dungeon and raid bosses.

Most importantly,

1. this only applies to players that enter dungeons and raids, so the casual overland player is not affected,
2. this only applies to players over CP300, so new players (and I think we are being generous here) are not affected.

So what happens to the tourist that just wants to experience the story of a dungeon or raid without contributing in any meaningful way? There should be an option for the party leader to mark a player as "tourist," which allows this player to be exempt from any dps obligations, thus protecting them from deletion based on the run.

Obviously, healers and tanks are not affected by this, only damage dealers.

Wow
How about deleting stupid player aswell?

Scratching my head here. You mean delete stupid forum trolls?

I wouldn't mind that either, if open-minded, innovative thinkers are not affected.

sevomd69

Vimora wrote: »

idk wrote: »

Vimora wrote: »

Did someone say delete WGT? Ok, this gave me an idea. How about deleting bad players? Let's say the worst 5% players every month that is calculated based on dps vs. dungeon and raid bosses.

Obviously, healers and tanks are not affected by this, only damage dealers.

So, eventually we have a bunch of tanks and at least half of them bad with only the top 10-20% of the DPS remaining. So, if you cannot pull, maybe, 35k DPS on a test dummy you are outa here. May take a few months but it will be coming.

OP is might just be a tank or healer and does not want to worry about being cut.

Really seems short sighted. Granted, OP is probably not serious, but still, an absurd idea to post.

It sounds absurd. But think about it. We are talking CP300+ damage dealers, who couldn't be bothered to l2p in the probably 300+ random dungeons that you can run before reaching this CP level. While they are ruining 3 other players' experience. So I get it, I might sound evil on the surface but is this really that unreasonable?

Yeah... it really is...

Danksta

That'd be a great incentive to try new, difficult content.

Derra

Rouven wrote: »

Vimora wrote: »

(...)

Obviously, healers and tanks are not affected by this, only damage dealers.

To clarify, there are no bad players that play as tanks or healers?

For a bad healer or tank there are only bad DDs

PurpleDrank

Asardes

Well, that actually gave me an idea. Not deletion, but a ranking system that allows you to give marks to players at the end of the dungeon, 1-5 stars. Queue positioning should be based on rating so a player with good rating gets to be picked before one with bad one. Over time people who have a bad attitude and/or bad play style and don't want to improve will get picked less often in random groups.

Shardan4968

PurpleDrank wrote: »

Exactly...

eso_nya

Asardes wrote: »

Well, that actually gave me an idea. Not deletion, but a ranking system that allows you to give marks to players at the end of the dungeon, 1-5 stars. Queue positioning should be based on rating so a player with good rating gets to be picked before one with bad one. Over time people who have a bad attitude and/or bad play style and don't want to improve will get picked less often in random groups.

Wont work out. Is to easy to bypass or even buy ratings. Imagine all the needy social guilds handing out free stars at the end of a normal run w/ one carry and 3 newbies.

anitajoneb17_ESO

Vimora wrote: »

I wouldn't mind that either, if open-minded, innovative thinkers are not affected.

I'm afraid you have a somewhat distorted or strange concept of "open mind", of "innovation" and probably of "think"... too.

and... HINT : there are GUILDS that do just what you want : kick low DPS players. Or better said, pre-select good players. That's OK because that's in their philosophy and goals. Just join them

Vimora

Asardes wrote: »

Well, that actually gave me an idea. Not deletion, but a ranking system that allows you to give marks to players at the end of the dungeon, 1-5 stars. Queue positioning should be based on rating so a player with good rating gets to be picked before one with bad one. Over time people who have a bad attitude and/or bad play style and don't want to improve will get picked less often in random groups.

Sounds good. Let's say a player is considered a novice until CP160. They can't be ranked yet, because they are only learning. After CP160 ranking is turned on and goes into effect.

ThePrinceOfBargains

Part of life and being social is sometimes dealing with difficult people in frustrating situations at varying frequencies. Don't know when some of you are finally going to realize this.

Asardes

You can simply put that rating in place just for solo queue in order not to allow easy rating farming.

theamazingx

Asardes wrote: »

Well, that actually gave me an idea. Not deletion, but a ranking system that allows you to give marks to players at the end of the dungeon, 1-5 stars. Queue positioning should be based on rating so a player with good rating gets to be picked before one with bad one. Over time people who have a bad attitude and/or bad play style and don't want to improve will get picked less often in random groups.

Would work out decently until salty baddies started 1-starring the whole group when they realized they were pulling 10% of the dps. I like the ranking idea conceptually, but the game doesn't have the population to support it with queues as long as they already are.

JamieAubrey

I'll delete my account now

OC_Justice

TheMaster wrote: »

Part of life and being social is sometimes dealing with difficult people in frustrating situations at varying frequencies. Don't know when some of you are finally going to realize this.

Or not dealing with them, and therefor VOTEKICK.

Had to boot a cp160 yesterday from FG2 because he wouldn't stop using ice staff. Even after we told him we were losing dps because he kept pulling him out of lightning and having to kite. UGGGGGGG tried to explain ice and aggro he wouldn't listen. We warned him, but he wouldn't listen, so he got the boot.

Vimora

anitajoneb17_ESO wrote: »

Vimora wrote: »

I wouldn't mind that either, if open-minded, innovative thinkers are not affected.

I'm afraid you have a somewhat distorted or strange concept of "open mind", of "innovation" and probably of "think"... too.

and... HINT : there are GUILDS that do just what you want : kick low DPS players. Or better said, pre-select good players. That's OK because that's in their philosophy and goals. Just join them

Isn't it ironic that the most opinionated people are always those that are playing their first MMO. According to my concept of open-minded, you are closed-minded. Why do you think you already know everything and you've already seen everything, while in fact, you've just started out in the genre? And yet, you are so self-certain and entitled that you think you know everything best. In every thread. No matter who you're talking to.

Vimora

TheMaster wrote: »

Part of life and being social is sometimes dealing with difficult people in frustrating situations at varying frequencies. Don't know when some of you are finally going to realize this.

This is why rules and regulations are in place in every field of life, because the average person can't be trusted to do the right thing.