Jennifur_Vultee wrote: »Wow that's a really deep post, its going to require a lot of thought on my part to properly reply with "No". Buying/selling/trading crowns should be illegal in game, a breach of the TOS that is punishable by banning.
Do you remember when everyone was happy about gold sellers being gone?
[reminiscence]
Adding gold into the crown store would just be a way to bring them back in a legal manner, with @ZOS approval.
What would be the advantage cash shop gold vs gold seller gold?
With the payment change comes the opportunity for ESO to earn more cash for a healthy future, through a variety of combinations. People like me who will subscibe and also drop cash on the marketplace on boosts and fluff, those who buy DLC, those who buy DLC and fluff etc.
But without having a means of gifting Crowns/items ingame ZOS could be missing a trick. There will always be people without access to credit cards or much disposable income who would play, and grind away incessantly to earn gold in game with which to buy Subs/items/DLC from those with lots of spare cash but not so much time.
If gifting and crown exchange is in place then you could quite reasonably expect one cash rich casual player to actually be purchasing their own sub, but also potentially buy three or four other subs from people who are time/gold rich in game.
Everquest 2 has an it's called a Krono for example, which you purchase from the SOE online store for a little more than 1month recurring sub. It then is delivered to you in game and is tradeable to other players. Once bought it can be used to furnish the buyer with one months sub.
With the basic premise that more people playing equals more community, more player generated online presence and a better future for the game it seems shortsighted to not at least consider implementing such a system.
AlexDougherty wrote: »I'm actually hoping everything in Crown store will be BOP, the fact stuff was resold through GTM ruined trading in SWTOR, want to sell Armour, nobody's interested unless it's the latest model (with a blinking light that stops blinking in three months for no reason).
So I am literally hoping that the cash shop is self only and Bind on Pickup.
Jennifur_Vultee wrote: »Wow that's a really deep post, its going to require a lot of thought on my part to properly reply with "No". Buying/selling/trading crowns should be illegal in game, a breach of the TOS that is punishable by banning.
It's going to happen anyway and people will get burned it, so why not do it properly and get more development cash from it.
MornaBaine wrote: »No cash to gold conversion please. The potential abuse is staggering. Not to mention it would wreck the in-game economy and truly would be a "pay to win" option as you can buy a lot of really good gear from guild stores. So no, just no.
However, EA did something very smart with The Sims 3. In their cash shop/DLC shop they made it so that you could gift any of the items to other players. When I was playing that game heavily not only did I often receive gifts but I bought an awful lot of them as well. You did this, of course, by buying "Sim Points" and then when you clicked on an item in the store to peruse it there were options to both buy for yourself and gift. So potentially you could do the same thing with buying ESO's crowns. This is probably the ONLY thing that could get me to cheerfully purchase additional crowns over and above what I get via my sub. As a guild leader I would love to be able to reward our members this way and be able to use items from the store as "prizes" and "treasure" in conjunction with our guild sponsored activities. For although I am against the creation of ESO's store in the first place, since it's inevitable, I may as well suggest something that would make it more palatable to me AND that would make ESO a ton more cash.
With the payment change comes the opportunity for ESO to earn more cash for a healthy future, through a variety of combinations. People like me who will subscibe and also drop cash on the marketplace on boosts and fluff, those who buy DLC, those who buy DLC and fluff etc.
But without having a means of gifting Crowns/items ingame ZOS could be missing a trick. There will always be people without access to credit cards or much disposable income who would play, and grind away incessantly to earn gold in game with which to buy Subs/items/DLC from those with lots of spare cash but not so much time.
If gifting and crown exchange is in place then you could quite reasonably expect one cash rich casual player to actually be purchasing their own sub, but also potentially buy three or four other subs from people who are time/gold rich in game.
Everquest 2 has an it's called a Krono for example, which you purchase from the SOE online store for a little more than 1month recurring sub. It then is delivered to you in game and is tradeable to other players. Once bought it can be used to furnish the buyer with one months sub.
With the basic premise that more people playing equals more community, more player generated online presence and a better future for the game it seems shortsighted to not at least consider implementing such a system.
Jennifur_Vultee wrote: »MornaBaine wrote: »No cash to gold conversion please. The potential abuse is staggering. Not to mention it would wreck the in-game economy and truly would be a "pay to win" option as you can buy a lot of really good gear from guild stores. So no, just no.
However, EA did something very smart with The Sims 3. In their cash shop/DLC shop they made it so that you could gift any of the items to other players. When I was playing that game heavily not only did I often receive gifts but I bought an awful lot of them as well. You did this, of course, by buying "Sim Points" and then when you clicked on an item in the store to peruse it there were options to both buy for yourself and gift. So potentially you could do the same thing with buying ESO's crowns. This is probably the ONLY thing that could get me to cheerfully purchase additional crowns over and above what I get via my sub. As a guild leader I would love to be able to reward our members this way and be able to use items from the store as "prizes" and "treasure" in conjunction with our guild sponsored activities. For although I am against the creation of ESO's store in the first place, since it's inevitable, I may as well suggest something that would make it more palatable to me AND that would make ESO a ton more cash.
Sending gifts sounds fine as long as items remain bind on pickup. I'm in no way in favor of a cash shop and I've seen what happens to a game economy when cash shop items are freely tradable/sellable in game....its not pretty. But yeah sure if you want to help a friend and you're willing to send them a gift of a Speckled Guar Mount or Lusty Argonian Maid costume that's bind on pickup go for it, its your cash.
AlexDougherty wrote: »I'm actually hoping everything in Crown store will be BOP, the fact stuff was resold through GTM ruined trading in SWTOR, want to sell Armour, nobody's interested unless it's the latest model (with a blinking light that stops blinking in three months for no reason).
So I am literally hoping that the cash shop is self only and Bind on Pickup.
It was stated that all cash shop items bind to account immediately upon purchase.
AlexDougherty wrote: »I'm actually hoping everything in Crown store will be BOP, the fact stuff was resold through GTM ruined trading in SWTOR, want to sell Armour, nobody's interested unless it's the latest model (with a blinking light that stops blinking in three months for no reason).
So I am literally hoping that the cash shop is self only and Bind on Pickup.
It was stated that all cash shop items bind to account immediately upon purchase.
MornaBaine wrote: »Jennifur_Vultee wrote: »Sending gifts sounds fine as long as items remain bind on pickup. I'm in no way in favor of a cash shop and I've seen what happens to a game economy when cash shop items are freely tradable/sellable in game....its not pretty. But yeah sure if you want to help a friend and you're willing to send them a gift of a Speckled Guar Mount or Lusty Argonian Maid costume that's bind on pickup go for it, its your cash.
Since they've already said the items in the shop will be bound and can't be sold in game I didn't think to mention it but yes, certainly, items gifted should also be bound to the account they were purchased for. Absolutely no way should they find their way into the in game economy!
Do you remember when everyone was happy about gold sellers being gone?
[reminiscence]
Adding gold into the crown store would just be a way to bring them back in a legal manner, with @ZOS approval.
What would be the advantage cash shop gold vs gold seller gold?
Frenkthevile wrote: »NOPE, if they do something like this i'll quit. GW2 economy was RUINED the same way.
You and I must play different games called GW2 because I recall no such sky collapse.Frenkthevile wrote: »NOPE, if they do something like this i'll quit. GW2 economy was RUINED the same way.
Thus starts the funeral march for eso........
The difference is that now ZOS has a system in place which would allow them to easily do it.nerevarine1138 wrote: »Thus starts the funeral march for eso........
Why didn't the funeral march start almost a year ago, when a select few people were advocating for ZO to sell gold in order to combat gold sellers?
This isn't a new idea, nor is it specific to the new payment model. It's still an awful idea, but the overwhelming majority of people recognize that. So nothing's changed.
AlexDougherty wrote: »Frenkthevile wrote: »NOPE, if they do something like this i'll quit. GW2 economy was RUINED the same way.
How was is ruined exactly? GW2 system actually takes gold out of the economy, not add to it.
If it was anything like Swtor prices destabilised.
When Swtor launched it's cash shop prices for crafted stuff vanished (they were inferior looks, clearly inferior), and it started a weird cycle for prices on GTM.
New stuff was priced high.
Rare stuff was priced insanely high.
Stuff from a couple of months was about what the crafted gear used to be.
Stuff from a bit further back was going for buttons.
It really did destabilise Swtor's GTM economy.